I fully agree that REM have not released anything as good as Automatic since then, but then again, in my opinion, that's one of the best albums of all time. But to write off all of their work since then would be a mistake.
Hi-Fi was good, as good as Monster anyway, if not better.
Up was okay. Some good, but mostly mediocre stuff.
But has anyone heard Reveal? It kind of slipped under the radar. But in my opinion, it's the best REM album since Automatic, hands down. In fact, it was my favorite album of 2001. Reveal is great. It reminds me alot of Summer Teeth by Wilco.
Relevant: Prince, PT Anderson, Punk, Post-Punk, Purple, Party of Five, Peter Swanson, Peter Gabriel-led Genesis, "Peter Panic", Paul's Boutique, Potential Energy, Every Features MB member but me.