The comparisons to "Take Me Out" and Float On, off as they are for aesthetic reasons (I think the "Tonight Tonight" video is a much closer match in that regard), neglect part of what made those videos a great way to introduce those bands to the world: they presented the bands as, well, bands. There is nothing in the "Leave It All Behind" video that makes it readily apparent that the characters on screen are a band that plays music in the real world in which we live. And that's why it doesn't work for me. When I took my friends to see the band a couple of days ago, one of them had only seen this video, and had no other exposure to the band. Boy was he surprised, and pleasantly! When the band took that stage, he suggested that it'd be great if Matt were wearing the pirate hat. It just felt like all of the wrong things to latch onto, things that fall away immediately if we see the band as a band. It is all about the music, after all, and we can't really connect them to that, so it ends up being about the image vs the audio, and audio never wins that fight in the psyche. So the image makes more of an impression, and people identify the Features less with the song they heard than with the goofy pirate antics they saw.
Say what you will about performance videos (I personally like videos that offer a mix of performance and concept), they do
connect the band to the music that you hear. And for a new band that audiences don't know, that's key. Peacefrog's videos, especially "Million Ways," become perfect for a new band: they're new and interesting, but the celebrate the band as a musical concern above all else. They cement the musical aspect of the experience to your impression of the band. And that's the most important part of all.
The video just doesn't work for me. It's the kind of concept that only works for people that know the band (and then not universally). U2 could pull something like this off; people know who they're looking at in that case. Meanwhile, The Features need to make a good first impression. I hope that, for most people thet hear them, this isn't it.
(Opinionated) Will
You may like grandma's yard gnomes, but I've seen Rock City. Remember it.