A message board standard--

What are your Top 5 (10 if you need it) albums -- in no particular order???

Here are mine (at the moment)

1. Fluid Ounces -- In the New Old-Fashioned Way
2. Mike Watt -- Contemplating the Engine Room
3. The Beatles -- Abbey Road
4. REM -- Ouchamatic for the People
5. Dos -- Justamente Tres
6. Flaming Lips -- The Soft Bulletin
7. Sonic Youth -- Washing Machine

OK, it's more than 5.
Also, the Features are not mentioned because their official releases on their own are not so strong in light of their larger body of music unreleased and unrecorded.

Flame me if you like but...

1.  The Beatles - The White Album
2.  Blur - Parklife
3.  Blur - The Great Escape
4.  Self - Breakfast With Girls (vinyl, w/ 5 extra tracks)
5.  REM - Automatic for the People

Honorable Mention:

6. Wilco - Summerteeth
7. The Beastie Boys - Check Your Head
8. The Beatles - Abbey Road
9. Kula Shaker - Peasants, Pigs, & Astronauts
10. U2 - Achtung Baby

(Edited by jamiecarroll at 11:10 pm on April 10, 2002)

The Beatles - Abbey Road
Clem Snide - Ghost of Fashion
Weezer - Weezer (Blue)
They Might Be Giants - Flood
Mark Eitzel - Caught In A Trap And I Can't Back Out Cause I Love You Too Much, Baby

(no particular order)

Everybody seems to like Abbey Road.  It is definitely The Beatles' best album.  The White Album is the Beatles trying to sound like other bands.  Still good, but Abbey Road is better.

(Edited by HeyItsBriggs at 11:52 pm on April 10, 2002)

That's a bold statement.

That's quite a bold statement as well, and I would beg to differ. I would put both the White Album and Revolver ahead of Abbey Road.

whoa look out. keith talkin' some beatles! do the beatles even still get played in that house?

not tops, just what i'm listening to as of now...
1. the features -3.28.02
2. uncle tupelo - anthology 89/93
3. beach boys - friends
4. nuggets vol II, disc 2
5. pere ubu - 360 degrees of simulated strereo
6. michael jackson - off the wall
7. some foo fighters stuff from the first one and the colour and the shape that i downloaded.

top 5

Brute - Cobalt
Outkast - ATLiens
Bob Dylan - Blonde on Blonde
Elliott Smith - Either/Or
Bob Marley - Natty Dread

5 honorable mention

Nirvana - In Utero
Widespread Panic - Widespread Panic a.k.a. Mama's Kitchen
Belle and Sebastian - Fold Your Hands Child You Walk Like a Peasant
Beck - Mutations
Blur - Parklife

and what would this list be without some county and bluegrass

Johnny Cash - At Folsom Prison
Bill Monroe - Live From the Mountain Stage
OCMS - Eutaw
David Allen Coe - For the Record: The First 10 Years





(Edited by blightman at 12:46 pm on April 11, 2002)

Hey, just because we live with Capt. Avant Garde doesn't mean the two semi-normal members of the house can't listen to music that 'everyone else' likes.

My top five right now in no order:
Jellyfish- Spilt Milk
Radiohead- The Bends
JMB- Around The Year With Joe Marc's Brother
Air- The Virgin Suicides
Sly & The Family Stone- Anthology (ok, so that isn't a real album, but it rules).

wow, i was just discussing the 'possibilities' of the virgin suicides soundtrack with jamiecarroll and neuboy this weekend.

the six cds in my car right now:
pet sounds
trans am
how i quit smoking
'garage rock operas and more'
white album
internal wrangler

p.s. i highly approve of 'off the wall.' you're this generation's savior, lawnwrangler, lead on.

Radiohead - OK Computer/The Bends (can't decide which I like better)
Nirvana - Nevermind
Beatles - Revolver
The Replacements - that Greatest Hits thing they put out a few years ago...
Elliott Smith - Either/Or
Smashing Pumpkins - Siamese Dream

queen freeze- that 'garage rock operas'wouldn't happen to be the lost lifeboy album would it? i'd kill for a copy on cd. i lent out my cassette a couple of years ago and never got it back.

keith- you should buy, er, i mean download, sly's 'fresh.' greatest funk album ever. very organic, not too over the top. dope shit.

beatles - abbey road (good call, everyone!)
tori amos - from the choirgirl hotel
nirvana - nevermind
jane's addiciton - nothing's shocking
REM - automatic for the people
counting crows - august and everyhting after
mates of state - my solo project
jeff buckley - grace
led zepellin IV
unified theory

LW, I can probably help you out with Garage Rock Operas. I do own 'Fresh,' but the Anthology has 20 songs packed on 1 CD. Can't beat that.

Not necessarily in this order, but close to it:

1. Simon & Garfunkel - Sounds of Silence
2. Beach Boys - Pet Sounds
3. Beatles - Abbey Road
4. Stone Roses - Stone Roses
5. Kula Shaker - Peasants, Pigs, & Astronauts
6. Simon & Garfunkel - Wednesday Morning, 3 A.M.
7. Doors - Waiting for the Sun
8. Weezer - Weezer (blue)

...that's all I can think of off the top of my head.
here's some honorable mentions:

Bernard Butler - Friends & Lovers
Beatles - Rubber Soul
White Stripes - White Stripes
Led Zeppelin I
Blur- Parklife
Superdrag - Headtrip in Every Key/Regretfully Yours (both really good for totally different reasons)

ok, I had better stop now...

I'm not saying The White Album is bad because they are trying to sound like other bands they just are.. check it out:

Back in the USSR - Beach Boys (written with Mike Love I believe)
ObLaDi ObLaDa - Their take on jamacian type music
Yer Blues - Tryin to be like Cream
Helter Skelter - McCartney read a review of The Who and that's what he imagined the music would wound like.

There's more, that's just off the top of my head. Still a good album, I mean, that's what they did their whole carreer.. experimented with lots of different sounds. 'Hide Your Love Away' is just Lennon experimenting with Dylan's sound. Abbey Road is still better though.

Back in the USSR - I have never, in all of my time as a Beatles fan, heard that Mike Love had anything to do with this song (or any Beatles song).  You may be right, but I've never heard that before.  Anyway, I don't think they're trying trying to sound like the Beach Boys.  I think it's kind of a sarcastic *reaction* to all of the Beach Boys' sunny happy surf music.  The White Album is pretty dark in spaces, and I think that this is just setting the stage for that.

ObLaDi ObLaDa - Jamacian music?  Do you mean reggae?  Maybe they were trying something different, but I don't think that they were trying to sound like anything in particular.

Yer Blues - Okay, I might give you this one, especially since they were hanging out with Clapton.  But keep in mind that ALOT of bands were doing this kind of 'electric blues' at the time, so they could've just been following a trend in general.

Helter Skelter - The story goes that Paul read an interview with Pete Townshend where he said that they'd just recorded the 'loudest, nastiest rock song ever.'  Paul then tried to write what he thought was the loudest, nastiest rock song ever, NOT something that would sound like the Who.  Because if you listen to it, Helter Skelter does not sound like the Who.

Hide Your Love Away - A Dylan impersonation, you're very right.

I don't know, Briggs.  I think that there are touches of other bands' music in the White Album.  But there are touches of other bands' music in almost any album.  I think that it would be a mistake to write the White Album off completely as 'the Beatles trying to sound like other bands.'  I like Abbey Road, too.  It's my second favorite Beatles album.

Hide Your Love Away -- on Help!, not the White Album


Worst post ever.

I'm sorry you didn't like it YDDD.  I was just responding to Briggs' criticisms.  I know that Hide Your Love Away isn't on the White Album, but he mentioned it, so I responded to it.

i don't get that 'white album sounds like them imitating other bands' business. me and neuboy(rip)were actually discussing originality in music the other day. we both agree that no art is original. for that matter neither is any idea.....or action. i hate bands that act like they're completely original. the only bands that have come close are joy division, the beatles(at moments and with no small help from sir george martin), kraftwerk, can, mission of burma(on vs.),....blah blah. i don't suppose it matters anyway.

I was kidding JC because I felt like the Comic Book Guy from the Simpsons when I pointed out such a minute thing.

ELT is right too.

I agree that all music created at this point is comprised of elements of things that have come before.  But doesn't a unique new configuration or arrangement of those elements constitute something original?  I suppose it's not completely original, but there's something to be said for finding interesting new ways of mixing and matching and presenting the elements of what's been done before...I think there's some degree of originality to that.

(Edited by jamiecarroll at 11:44 pm on April 15, 2002)

I think of it as more of a complication than an innovation when something 'new' comes along.