
Quote from DigsySlattery on Oct. 6, 2003 at 12:07 PM

I read that list a week or so ago and I have to say that it is quite lame. I know pitchforkmedia is all about indie cred and being cool, but they left off every CD that really are the most common used CDs. "Tubthumper"? "Yourself or Someone Like You?" The Rembrandt's "LP"? Yes, even "Be Here Now." Geez.
Yeah, and here's why.
And I quote:
"...naturally, questions of volume and locale weigh heavily against how accurate I could really be here, so in aid of making it a more worthwhile guide, I disqualified all but a select few egregious and relevant examples from the the former class [volume]. You will not find Matchbox 20's
Yourself or Someone Like You atop this list, though it is unquestionably the most widely available used compact disc in America as of this writing.
There's a dual benefit to
ignoring platinum titles: I don't have to write about piece of shit records like Hootie & The Blowfish's
Fairweather Johnson, Third Eye Blind's
Blue, or Bush's
Sixteen Stone. Grunge has been dead since the age of Collective Soul and Candlebox-- thousands of copies of
Badmotorfinger sold back by aging yuppies sit in dusty piles as proof-- but beyond questions of aesthetics and scope, I think it'd be an insult to our readership if I presumed you needed any help avoiding The Cranberries, Toad the Wet Sprocket and Live. Dada, though..."
(Edited by jamiecarroll at 3:29 am on Oct. 7, 2003)
Relevant: Prince, PT Anderson, Punk, Post-Punk, Purple, Party of Five, Peter Swanson, Peter Gabriel-led Genesis, "Peter Panic", Paul's Boutique, Potential Energy, Every Features MB member but me.