Well, I've waited and listened and waited and listened, trying to fully digest
Speakerboxxx/The Love Below before I gave my opinion on it. And I think now it's time:
Speakerboxxx: 3.5 stars
The Love Below: 2 stars
I don't know. I guess maybe I built this double album up too much in my mind beforehand. But I am severely let down by it, ESPCIALLY by Andre's half.
Speakerboxxx was better than I expected it to be. I thought that it would be a pretty generic-sounding rap album, but it's much better than that. To me, it just sounds like OutKast (a GOOD thing). It definitely pushes the boundaries of mainstream hip-hop, but it still manages to sound very much like what OutKast has done in the past.
The Love Below? I don't know exactly
what went wrong. Here's what pitchforkmedia.com said:
"As it turns out, his Prince-mimicking fusion looks a lot better on paper than it sounds in your ears."
I think that's what I'm feeling about this. I have so much RESPECT for Andre: he wrote nearly every song on his album BY HIMSELF, he produced the whole album BY HIMSELF, and he played guitars, played keyboards, and made beats for the album, too. While Big Boi has been perfectly content to be "just a rapper," Andre has gone out and taken creative control of the entire process. I respect that so much. But the actual music is just not that good. In fact, some of it is really terrible. There are definitely
glimpses of greatness. "Hey Ya" still rules me. I think that maybe if Andre keeps at it, he can make really incredible music BY HIMSELF someday. But right now, I think he still needs Big Boi and Organized Noize.
The pitchfork review of this is right on. You can read it
here. (Edited by jamiecarroll at 3:07 pm on Oct. 9, 2003)
Relevant: Prince, PT Anderson, Punk, Post-Punk, Purple, Party of Five, Peter Swanson, Peter Gabriel-led Genesis, "Peter Panic", Paul's Boutique, Potential Energy, Every Features MB member but me.